Selecting a mining pool is not a matter of finding a single “best” provider. It is a comparison exercise that depends on the coin and algorithm a miner's hardware supports, the payout method a pool offers, how merged-mining rewards are accounted for, and a pool's published fee and withdrawal terms. This article sets out a practical comparison set for Bitcoin (SHA-256) and for Litecoin/Dogecoin (Scrypt), and explains the variables that matter more than any single headline fee.
Why Algorithm Compatibility Comes First
Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash use SHA-256d, while Litecoin and Dogecoin use Scrypt. An SHA-256 ASIC cannot mine Litecoin or Dogecoin, and a Scrypt ASIC cannot mine Bitcoin; the two hardware classes require separate pool connections and are not interchangeable despite both being purpose-built ASICs. This means a Bitcoin miner and a Litecoin/Dogecoin miner are, in practice, comparing two different sets of pools.
Bitcoin (SHA-256): A Practical Comparison Set
For Bitcoin, a reasonable comparison set includes ViaBTC, Foundry USA Pool, F2Pool, AntPool, and Braiins Pool. Each represents a different combination of payout method, scale, and account features.
ViaBTC's BTC pool offers PPS+ and PPLNS as payout methods and supports merged mining for Namecoin (NMC) and Fractal Bitcoin (FB). Choosing PPS+ for BTC does not change how FB is paid: FB is allocated under its own PPLNS rule, independent of the parent BTC payout method. Foundry USA Pool documents an FPPS model, with prior-day earnings calculated and credited daily at a fixed UTC time, which is a useful benchmark for miners prioritizing predictable daily accounting. Foundry is positioned as an institutional-grade pool and requires KYC/AML onboarding, so miners should confirm account-opening requirements and access before planning a test. F2Pool and AntPool are additional candidates to evaluate for their BTC payout terms and account features, while Braiins Pool offers configurable payout rules and Lightning payout options.
A pool's share of recently found blocks can provide context about its operating scale, but it is not a profitability ranking, a customer-count metric, or a measure of connection latency to any specific mining location. Any block-share comparison should identify its observation window and retrieval time rather than treating a changing dashboard figure as a permanent characteristic of the pool.
Litecoin and Dogecoin (Scrypt): A Practical Comparison Set
For Scrypt hardware, the more useful comparison is usually among Litecoin pools that support Dogecoin merged mining (AuxPoW), rather than between separate LTC and DOGE connections. A compatible Scrypt miner points its hashrate at the Litecoin pool, and the pool's software simultaneously submits valid shares toward Dogecoin's blockchain when permitted by the AuxPoW protocol.
A reasonable comparison set for Litecoin and Dogecoin includes ViaBTC, F2Pool, and LitecoinPool.org, each of which treats the merged reward differently.
At ViaBTC, the LTC pool offers PPS+ or PPLNS for Litecoin, and miners also receive merged-mining rewards in DOGE, BELLS, PEP, and DINGO. These four auxiliary coins are allocated under PPLNS regardless of which payout method is selected for LTC — choosing PPS+ for the Litecoin side does not convert DOGE, BELLS, PEP, or DINGO into a PPS+ reward. (PEP refers to Pepecoin, distinct from the unrelated PEPE token.) Because BELLS, PEP, and DINGO each follow their own issuance and reward rules on their respective chains, miners should not assume their reward behavior mirrors Dogecoin's.
F2Pool also documents a separate PPLNS-based allocation for DOGE and other merged-mining coins alongside its LTC payout rules. Before starting a test, miners must add a payout address for each merged-mining coin they want to receive: F2Pool states that the corresponding rewards only begin accruing after the address is added, and rewards from before that point are forfeited and will not be reissued.
LitecoinPool.org takes a different approach: LTC and DOGE are each credited under PPS and paid directly in their respective coins, with the same nominal PPS fee rate applied to both. Other merged-mining coins are not paid directly in their original currencies; instead, they help support a higher PPS ratio for LTC and DOGE. This contrast illustrates that “merged mining” does not mean the same accounting treatment across pools — it is a variable to confirm on each pool's own documentation, not an assumption to carry over from one pool to another.
Payout Methods Are Not Interchangeable Labels
The payout-method terms used across these pools should not be treated as synonyms:
- PPS: The pool pays for valid shares under a formula based on network difficulty and the block subsidy, rather than making those payments depend on whether the pool actually finds a block. The rate can change as the formula's inputs change.
- PPS+: Combines a PPS-based block-subsidy component with a transaction-fee component distributed under PPLNS. At ViaBTC, this means the subsidy component is insulated from pool block-finding luck, while the transaction-fee component still depends on the pool's actual blocks and the fees they contain.
- FPPS: A PPS-style method that also factors in an allowance for average transaction fees, used by pools such as Foundry USA.
- PPLNS: Rewards are calculated from the miner's share of contributions within a defined recent window (a set number of prior difficulty rounds), and are only distributed when the pool actually finds a block. Short-term variance is generally higher under PPLNS than under PPS-style methods, because pool luck affects the timing and size of payouts.
Headline fee percentages are not directly comparable unless the payout method, the treatment of transaction fees, and whether merged-mining rewards are included in the same figure are all specified. A 2% fee under one method and a 4% fee under another may produce different net results depending on these factors.
Connectivity and Payout Controls Worth Checking
Beyond payout method and fee, a practical comparison should also cover:
- Regional and backup stratum endpoints, and whether SSL/TLS connections are offered.
- Worker-level hashrate reporting and alerts for idle or disconnected workers.
- Minimum withdrawal thresholds per asset, and whether automatic or manual withdrawal is supported.
- Whether a withdrawable merged-mining coin can also be converted to another asset within the platform, since conversion eligibility and withdrawal eligibility are governed by separate rules and can change independently. For example, ViaBTC's conversion service has at times adjusted which coins it supports for in-platform conversion, separate from whether those same coins can be withdrawn on-chain — a distinction worth confirming on the current product pages rather than assuming from a general merged-mining description.
- Security controls such as two-factor authentication and payout-address protections.
These factors do not change a pool's gross payout formula, but they materially affect how reliably and conveniently a miner can actually access earned balances.
A Practical Way to Run the Comparison
Rather than comparing a single headline fee across pools, a more reliable approach is to mine on each candidate pool for the same number of days, under similar network difficulty and similar hashrate conditions, and compare net mining earnings across the primary coin and any merged-mining rewards. If credited earnings already have the pool fee deducted, do not subtract that fee again. When combining multiple coins into one value, use the same valuation time and price source for all candidates so that price movements between tests do not distort the comparison.
Keep earnings and withdrawal access separate. A balance below the withdrawal threshold is still an earned balance; record it alongside amounts already paid out, and assess withdrawal thresholds, delays, and withdrawal fees as separate practical factors. Allow for rewards from the test that are credited later because of confirmation requirements or PPLNS settlement timing, including any rewards credited after switching away.
Because PPLNS-based rewards, including merged-mining rewards at ViaBTC and F2Pool, vary with pool luck, a short test window of a few hours is not sufficient to draw conclusions; a longer, consistent period gives a more representative picture. Even then, results remain observations from that period rather than proof that one pool will always pay more. This approach also surfaces practical issues, such as withdrawal thresholds or idle-worker alerting, that a fee schedule alone will not reveal.
Conclusion
For Bitcoin, a reasonable comparison set is ViaBTC, Foundry USA Pool, F2Pool, AntPool, and Braiins Pool, spanning PPS+, FPPS, and PPLNS models at meaningfully different scales. For Litecoin and Dogecoin, compare ViaBTC, F2Pool, and LitecoinPool.org, paying particular attention to how each pool accounts for merged-mining rewards rather than assuming all three handle DOGE the same way. In both cases, the decisive factors are the payout method, the treatment of transaction fees and merged-mining rewards, published fee and withdrawal terms, server availability relative to the mining site, and measured results from a consistent test period — not a single headline fee or a short-term revenue estimate.
FAQ
Can I mine Dogecoin directly without connecting to a Litecoin pool?
Some pools market Dogecoin mining as part of a Litecoin connection through merged mining (AuxPoW), since Dogecoin and Litecoin share the Scrypt algorithm. Whether a given pool requires a separate Dogecoin stratum connection or delivers DOGE automatically through its Litecoin pool depends on that pool's specific setup, so this should be confirmed on the pool's own documentation rather than assumed.
Does choosing PPS+ for Litecoin change how Dogecoin is paid?
At ViaBTC, no. DOGE, BELLS, PEP, and DINGO follow PPLNS regardless of whether you select PPS+ or PPLNS for LTC. These are separate payout rules, not independently selectable payout settings for each auxiliary coin. Other pools may use different rules, so check their documentation rather than assuming ViaBTC's arrangement applies everywhere.
Is a pool's block-share percentage a measure of profitability?
No. A pool's share of recently found blocks reflects its hashrate scale over a given window, not an individual miner's net return. Net return depends on the payout method, fee, variance, and the miner's own hardware performance over a comparable period.
Should I pick the pool with the lowest published fee?
Not necessarily. A lower fee under one payout method is not directly comparable to a higher fee under a different method, since PPS-style and PPLNS-style fees absorb different amounts of variance and may or may not include transaction fees or merged-mining rewards in the stated figure.
References
- ViaBTC Help Center, Mining Pools Information
- ViaBTC, Fees
- ViaBTC Help Center, LTC Merged Mining Coins Mining Tutorial
- ViaBTC Help Center, Fractal Bitcoin (FB) Mining
- mempool.space, Mining Dashboard
- Foundry Digital, Foundry USA Pool Payout Methodology
- Foundry Digital, Foundry USA Pool
- F2Pool Help Center, How to Mine Litecoin
- LitecoinPool.org, FAQ
- Braiins Academy, Rewards & Payouts


